Burncoat price tag looms over Worcester council agenda as city weighs school’s future

Worcester councilors get their first detailed look at Burncoat options ranging from $150 million to $710 million, alongside reports on e-bikes, police staffing, drones and fire hydrants and the return of a dispute over a tax-supported development

Worcester has known for years that Burncoat High School needs major work. On Tuesday, city councilors get a much clearer picture of just how expensive the choices could be.

Early estimates put the cost anywhere from $150 million for basic repairs to the existing high school to as much as $710 million for a major renovation and expansion encompassing both Burncoat High and Burncoat Middle schools. A completely new combined school is estimated at $635 million to $640 million.

Those numbers arrive with a blunt warning from the administration: Even with substantial state reimbursement, a project at the upper end of that range could add nearly $30 million in annual debt payments by the early 2030s and eventually force the city to consider significant tax increases or cuts elsewhere in the municipal budget.

The Burncoat report is among the most consequential items on a packed Sept. 29 city council agenda that also includes a detailed examination of Worcester’s increasingly ubiquitous e-bikes and scooters; new police reports on traffic enforcement, drone deployments and a coming wave of officers eligible for retirement; an accounting of the city’s out-of-service fire hydrants; and another round in the dispute over a subcontractor working on a Franklin Street housing development receiving city tax relief.

Burncoat choices come with price tags up to $710 million

The Burncoat School Building Project is still years from construction and no decision on a final design is before the council Tuesday. But the administration is putting the financial stakes on the table early.

Worcester entered the Massachusetts School Building Authority process after the city and Worcester Public Schools submitted a statement of interest for Burncoat High in 2021. The project is now in the feasibility-study stage, the third of nine steps in the MSBA process.

The city is giving a good look to two enrollment scenarios: a high school serving 1,400 students in grades 9-12, or a consolidated Burncoat High and Middle School serving 2,125 students in grades 7-12.

Each comes with three basic options.

For the high school alone, bringing the existing building up to current building and accessibility codes is estimated at $150 million to $165 million. Renovating and adding to the school is estimated at $455 million to $500 million, while building a new high school is estimated at $435 million to $460 million.

Including both the middle and high schools pushes the estimates considerably higher. A basic repair is projected at $250 million to $270 million; renovation and expansion at $685 million to $710 million; and construction of a new combined school at $635 million to $640 million.

The estimates are preliminary, and the city has not yet chosen a preferred option. A preferred schematic report is expected to go to the MSBA in March, with construction potentially beginning in May 2029. Under the current timeline, teachers and students would move into the completed school in August 2032, with final site work continuing through 2033.

The administration’s report makes clear that the decision extends far beyond school design.

Worcester had $981.8 million in outstanding debt as of June 30. Assuming the MSBA ultimately covers approximately half the cost, the administration estimates that renovating or replacing both Burncoat schools would increase municipal debt by about 30% and add upward of $25 million annually in debt service. Over three decades, the city estimates it would pay approximately $200 million in interest in addition to repaying the principal.

By the early 2030s, the administration projects the annual budget could need to absorb nearly $30 million in additional debt costs under a $710 million project—money that would otherwise compete with education, police, fire, public works and other services, as well as capital needs including police and fire stations, Worcester East Middle School and streets and sidewalks.

Chief of Public Facilities James Bedard warned in his report that without planning for the expense, the city could face “future years of budget cuts and/or double-digit tax increases.”

No council vote on the Burncoat project is required Tuesday. The administration is instead asking councilors to begin preparing financially. Bedard said he is prepared to recommend putting as much as $7.5 million in potential free cash into the New High School Fund if anticipated one-time revenue materializes. He is also calling for the council to commit $15 million of the city’s unused tax levy capacity beginning in fiscal 2028 to help absorb future Burncoat debt payments.

E-bikes are everywhere. The rules? Not so simple.

Anyone trying to figure out whether the electric bike, scooter or other motorized contraption zipping past them is legal—and where it is allowed to go—has some company.

The Department of Transportation and Mobility says the technology has moved faster than the laws governing it.

Transportation Commissioner Stephen Rolle will present councilors with a lengthy report outlining a regulatory system in which devices that may look nearly identical can fall under very different rules depending on their speed, power and design.

Massachusetts currently recognizes two classes of e-bikes. Class I provides electric assistance only while the rider pedals; Class II may also use a throttle. Both are limited to electric assistance of 20 mph and motors of no more than 750 watts.

Those e-bikes generally are regulated like conventional bicycles, don’t require registration and require helmets only for riders 16 and younger. They may use bike lanes but not Worcester sidewalks.

But some vehicles commonly called e-bikes aren’t legally e-bikes at all. Depending on their speed and specifications, they may instead qualify as mopeds, limited-use motorcycles or motorcycles, bringing different licensing, registration, insurance, helmet and operating requirements.

Motorized scooters fall under another set of rules, while newer devices such as powered one-wheel boards aren’t explicitly covered by current state law.

“Appearance alone is often misleading,” Rolle wrote, noting that inconsistent labeling and aftermarket modifications can make determining a vehicle’s legal classification difficult for riders and police alike.

Worcester isn’t proposing its own sweeping rewrite yet. A state commission issued recommendations in January aimed at modernizing Massachusetts’ micromobility laws, and related legislation remains under consideration. Rolle said DTM expects to work with the Law Department and Worcester Police on local changes once the state establishes an updated framework.

The city has meanwhile begun other safety efforts. UMass Memorial Health recently launched an E-Bike Safety Committee, with DTM participating, and Worcester Public Schools has created an online e-bike safety resource aimed in part at school-age riders.

Police reports track traffic enforcement, drones and looming retirements

A trio of reports from Police Chief Paul Saucier gives councilors a broader look at how the department is using its current workforce — and how many officers could soon be eligible to leave it.

WPD reports 21 retirements and seven resignations between September 2025 and September 2026. Five of those who resigned joined other departments, while two left law enforcement.

The potential retirement pool is considerably larger. Sixty-one sworn officers will be eligible for maximum retirement benefits by Dec. 31, rising to 79 by the end of 2027.

The department says it is trying to build its recruitment pipeline through information sessions, community partnerships, career fairs, school and college outreach and social media. A home-rule change signed this summer increased the maximum age for candidates taking the police civil service entrance examination for Worcester from 32 to 39.

Another report provides new numbers on traffic enforcement. The Traffic Division has conducted 1,466 assignments this year in response to complaints about specific locations and has issued 4,508 motor vehicle citations, according to Saucier.

The department has also permanently adopted the use of static blue “cruise” lights on marked police vehicles following a six-month pilot designed to increase police visibility and deter violations without requiring traffic stops.

WPD’s drones, meanwhile, were deployed for more than 10 operations between March 10 and Sept. 10. Uses included two SWAT operations, two crash reconstructions, a search for a missing person and security for major events including the St. Patrick’s Day Parade, Fourth of July fireworks and the Pan-Mass Challenge.

The department also conducted multiple drone flights in the Mill Street area during the week of Aug. 18 at the request of detectives. The report does not provide further information about the purpose of those flights.

Optiline dispute returns

A dispute over Optiline Enterprises, a drywall and metal-framing subcontractor working on the 364-unit residential development at 274 Franklin St., is also back before councilors after Councilor Gary Rosen held his own order under privilege Sept. 22.

Rosen is asking City Manager Eric Batista and Chief Development Officer Peter Dunn to explain why Optiline is working on the development, which Rosen’s order says is receiving $11 million in local property-tax relief over 15 years. He also wants the administration to determine whether the company’s involvement complies with Worcester’s Responsible Development Ordinance, which places labor-related requirements on projects receiving certain municipal incentives.

The order alleges a history of labor and employment violations by Optiline and says the company previously was barred from taxpayer-funded Worcester projects.

Documents submitted with Rosen’s order include a 2024 Suffolk Superior Court lawsuit brought by former Optiline worker Walter Astu individually and on behalf of similarly situated construction workers. That lawsuit alleges Optiline and company officials failed to pay required overtime wages. Those allegations are claims in pending litigation and should not be read as findings by the court.

Rosen’s supporting materials also describe subsequent enforcement and court actions involving the company, but the underlying orders and agency records were not included in the materials reviewed by the Guardian.

The issue is now broadening beyond the Franklin Street development. Council Vice Chairman Khrystian King has separate orders asking the administration to provide developers with a list of contractors and subcontractors ineligible to work in Worcester because of violations or noncompliance with the Responsible Development Ordinance, and to report on any wage-theft issues involving Optiline.

Other highlights on the agenda

🚒 Thirty-nine hydrants are out of service: Worcester has 6,084 fire hydrants, and 39 — about 0.64% — were out of service when Fire Chief Martin Dyer prepared his report. Nonfunctioning hydrants are marked by painting the bonnet black, while their status is also entered into a shared mapping system that refreshes every six hours and places an “X” over unavailable hydrants on the incident maps firefighters see when dispatched. The Water Division assesses reported problems and makes immediate repairs when possible; more complicated work may be coordinated with water-main shutdowns or larger street projects. Fire and DPW officials also review the list together and can prioritize repairs near high-risk buildings or critical facilities.

🗣️ 290 languages at firefighters’ fingertips: Worcester firefighters now have access to an iPad-based LanguageLine Solutions interpretation system capable of providing assistance in 290 languages. All Fire Department members were trained on the platform during the first week of September, and it went into service immediately afterward. Worcester EMS uses its own interpretation resources and procedures because it operates under a separate administrative structure and is not overseen by the city. The Fire Department says the new system is intended to reduce communication barriers during emergencies, when getting accurate information quickly can be critical.

🔊 Turning up the penalty for turning up the volume: A proposal to increase Worcester’s fines for excessive-noise violations returns after King held it under privilege Sept. 22. The Public Safety Committee chairman’s order asks the city manager to have the city solicitor draft an amendment to Worcester’s noise ordinance increasing the penalties. No proposed fine amounts are included in the order, so councilors aren’t being asked Tuesday to approve a particular new penalty. Instead, the question is whether to move forward with having the tougher ordinance drafted.

🚻 Public bathrooms, from temporary toilets to permanent facilities: Two held items put Worcester’s shortage of public bathrooms back before councilors. Bilotta and King want the administration to identify locations for permanent public restrooms, beginning in District 2, and consider porta-potties while permanent facilities are developed. A separate Bilotta order proposes using opioid settlement money to hire staff to monitor and maintain public bathrooms, citing programs in Miami and New York City as possible models. Together, the requests move the discussion beyond simply identifying restroom locations to the harder question of how facilities would be staffed and maintained.

🏠 A crash course for homeowners and tenants: Bilotta and Rosen want the city’s development office to work with housing organizations and other stakeholders on a New Homeowner and Tenant Summit. The event would educate residents about housing programs and benefits as well as tenants’ rights. The proposal was held under privilege by Bilotta last week and returns Tuesday. No date, location or program details have yet been established; the order asks the administration to begin developing the idea with housing partners.

🎨 Nearly $260,000 for Worcester arts: Councilors will consider accepting two grants for the Worcester Arts Council’s fiscal 2027 grant cycle: $244,500 from the Massachusetts Cultural Council and $15,000 from the Greater Worcester Community Foundation. The larger award supports grants available to individual artists, nonprofits, schools, libraries and other public and community organizations, with priorities including arts education, public art, musical performances and projects benefiting historically underserved communities. The foundation money is slated for Worcester Arts Council fellowships. Neither award requires a municipal match or additional city staff.

🧠 Nearly $473,000 for police crisis intervention: A $472,826 state Department of Mental Health grant would support Worcester police officers assigned to the Crisis Intervention Team and training intended to divert people experiencing mental or behavioral-health crises from the criminal justice system when appropriate. The money can reimburse the city for training time and backfilling shifts while officers attend 40-hour CIT courses, as well as approved behavioral-health training. WPD also plans to work with Community HealthLink, Open Sky, DMH and other behavioral-health organizations on the program. No local match or additional staffing is required.

👮 Another $128,251 for community policing: Worcester is eligible to apply for $128,251 through the federal Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant program. WPD proposes using the money to support quality-of-life work and maintain a monthly presence at 34 neighborhood and crime-watch meetings. The department says its Neighborhood Response Team plays a central role in that work because those officers aren’t tied to routine radio calls and can spend more time addressing neighborhood problems and working with residents and community organizations. The federal grant carries no municipal match requirement.

👥 Two appointments to the city’s youth commission: City Manager Eric Batista is recommending Echo Louissaint-Collins and Sharon Boateng for appointment to the Advisory Commission on Youth. Unlike appointments that can be made administratively, these require City Council confirmation. The appointments give councilors a comparatively straightforward personnel matter amid an agenda dominated by infrastructure, public safety and long-range financial questions.

Worcester City Council meets Tuesday, Sept. 29, at 6:30 p.m. in the Esther Howland Chamber at City Hall, 455 Main St. The meeting can also be watched online through the city’s government channel. The city’s published meeting schedule confirms the Sept. 29 meeting and its 6:30 p.m. start.