WORCESTER — UMass Memorial Medical Center received an estimated $17.7 million more in tax exemptions than it spent on community benefits in 2023, according to a new national report examining whether nonprofit hospitals are giving back enough to the communities they serve.
The Lown Institute, a Needham-based health care think tank, found that the Worcester hospital received an estimated $49.1 million in tax exemptions while spending $31.4 million on charity care and other community benefits. The difference, which the institute calls a “fair share” deficit, was among the six largest reported for Massachusetts hospitals.
The findings, released Tuesday, Nov. 17, raise questions about how nonprofit hospitals balance the financial advantages of their tax-exempt status with their obligations to provide care and services to the public.
Nonprofit hospitals receive exemptions from federal, state and local taxes in recognition of their charitable missions. In exchange, they are expected to provide benefits to their communities, including free or discounted medical care for patients who cannot afford treatment and programs addressing local health needs.
But how much hospitals should spend — and which expenses should count — remains a subject of debate.
The Lown Institute measures what it calls “fair share spending” by comparing the estimated value of a hospital’s tax exemptions with its spending on financial assistance, community health improvement programs, subsidized health services, charitable contributions and community-building activities.
Under that calculation, UMass Memorial’s community spending amounted to about 64% of the estimated value of its tax exemptions.
The report does not establish that UMass Memorial violated any law. Federal regulations require nonprofit hospitals to meet community benefit obligations but do not mandate that their spending equal the dollar value of their tax exemptions.
UMass Memorial Health did not provide a response to the report’s findings. Asked to address the $17.7 million gap and explain the hospital’s accounting of community benefit spending, spokesperson Kristy Lee told the Worcester Guardian on Friday that she had nothing to offer.
What counts as a community benefit?
A central issue in the report is how community benefits are defined.
The Lown Institute uses a narrower measure than the Internal Revenue Service, excluding several categories of spending that hospitals traditionally include when reporting their contributions to the public. Among those exclusions are medical research, education and training for health professionals, and the financial losses hospitals report when Medicaid reimbursements fall short of the cost of providing care. The institute argues that such spending does not necessarily translate into direct benefits for the communities surrounding hospitals.
Hospitals and industry representatives, however, contend that those activities are essential to their missions and provide substantial public value, even when the benefits are not immediately reflected in local charity care or community health programs. The distinction is particularly significant for large teaching hospitals such as UMass Memorial, where medical education, research and care for publicly insured patients are part of the broader health care mission.
Massachusetts hospitals show wide disparities
UMass Memorial was far from alone in recording a deficit under the institute’s methodology.
Massachusetts General Hospital had the state’s largest reported gap, at approximately $219 million, followed by Dana-Farber Cancer Institute at $134.9 million and Brigham and Women’s Hospital at $38.5 million. Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center reported a deficit of approximately $23 million, while Boston Children’s Hospital had a gap of nearly $21 million.
Other hospitals reported spending substantially more on community benefits than the estimated value of their tax exemptions. Boston Medical Center recorded a surplus exceeding $64 million, while Tufts Medical Center reported a surplus of more than $49 million.
The disparities reflect differences in hospital operations, patient populations and spending priorities, as well as the value of tax exemptions in communities where property values vary considerably.
Hospitals in areas with expensive real estate can receive particularly large property tax exemptions, increasing the amount they would need to spend on community benefits to meet the institute’s benchmark.
National findings raise broader questions
Nationwide, nonprofit hospitals received an estimated $38.8 billion in tax exemptions in 2023, according to the Lown Institute.
The analysis examined more than 3,000 hospitals across all 50 states and Washington, D.C., using federal tax filings, hospital cost reports and municipal property data. Of those hospitals, 52% received more in tax exemptions than they spent on the community benefits counted by the institute. Collectively, those hospitals recorded a $15.5 billion fair share deficit.
“Some of America’s wealthiest hospitals fall hundreds of millions short of giving back what they receive from their communities, leaving those with fewer resources to pick up the slack,” Dr. Vikas Saini, president of the Lown Institute, said in a statement. “Tax exemptions aren’t a gift—they’re an expectation, and regulators need to make sure all hospitals hold up their end of the bargain.”
The institute recommends that policymakers strengthen charity care standards, tighten community benefit reporting requirements and establish minimum spending targets for community investment.
A question of public benefit
The findings come amid broader scrutiny of the financial obligations of nonprofit hospitals, which operate as tax-exempt institutions while often functioning as some of the largest employers and economic engines in their communities.
The Lown Institute’s analysis does not suggest that hospitals reporting deficits provide no public benefit. Rather, it questions whether the value of their charitable contributions is sufficient to justify the tax advantages they receive.
For UMass Memorial, the report places a dollar figure on that debate: an estimated $17.7 million difference between the value of its tax exemptions and the community spending recognized under the institute’s methodology.
Whether that figure accurately reflects the hospital’s contributions to Worcester and the surrounding region depends in part on what should count as a community benefit—a question at the center of the debate over nonprofit hospital accountability.
